Written by leading analysts of international politics, ethics, and law, it seeks, among other things, to identify strategies that may, if not resolve, at least reduce the current tension between human rights and state sovereignty. It is the leading study on when humanitarian intervention will produce humanitarian results, and when it will only make things worse. This edited collection examines the challenges to international society posed by. Harvard university and harvard law school will shift to remote teaching and learning beginning monday, march 23. Noted author noam chomsky says, almost every aggressive act by any great power is justified on humanitarian grounds. For more information and the latest updates, please visit the hls coronavirus information page. Humanitarian intervention and international relations. In the context of the human securitynational security debate, the humani. Cambridge core human rights humanitarian intervention edited by j.
Humanitarian intervention head to head debate oxford. All this generated very fierce debate about what came to be called humanitarian intervention. Uncertainty arises as to whether there are any moral obligation for humanitarian intervention and the concerning justifications of the violation of state sovereignty. The effect of the intervention in libya on the international. The concentration of evaluation is to establish a link or lack of a link between programmatic resource finance, equipment, personnel, etc investment into a given humanitarian intervention with the results thereof. Extending freedom globally cambridge university press, 2015 with loren lomasky and humanitarian intervention. There have been 3 interventions that have qualified as humanitarian, but all of them were claimed to be purely selfinterested. Humanitarian intervention as an exceptional legal right 49 humanitarian intervention as morally andor politically acceptable 11 rejection of humanitarian intervention 34. Restructuring the debate on unauthorized humanitarian intervention saira mohamed scholars and practitioners addressing the problem of unauthorized humanitarian intervention often characterize the central difficulty of the issue as arising out of the fact that when the u. Stephen van evera professor of political science, massachusetts institute of technology. Humanitarian intervention under existing international law 80 2. Nov 04, 2010 this entry discusses humanitarian intervention as an autonomous justification for the use of force in international law.
This paper examines the legal status of humanitarian intervention in the aftermath of the abortive military operation in syria. The humanitarian part of the equation speaks to the motivation, and intervention implies the absence of the. The dilemma of humanitarian intervention muhammad hassan zia assistant professor university of the punjab gujranwala campus gujranwala, pakistan. Live debate humanitarian intervention does more harm than. Secondarily, however, the debate extends to the impact of humanitarian intervention on other interests, including the security and prosperity of intervening states and the spread of democracy. Humanitarian intervention thus invites us to rethink the ethical foundations of ir theory and the inherent tension between realism and moralism. It then addresses the legal, moral and political arguments in favour or against humanitarian intervention. Weiss as a moral minefield, the concept of humanitarian intervention has remained a topic of great debate among academics and politicians alike. Humanitarian responsibilities and interventionist claims in international society alex j. Humanitarian military intervention focuses on the questions of when and how. This wording also serves to emphasize the fact that the forces engaged in the intervention are bound by humanitarian law in their military operations. Humanitarian intervention essay sample sample essays. The legality of humanitarian intervention in customary.
Tes n is the tobias simon eminent scholar at florida state university college of law. The debate on humanitarian intervention japan center for. Us humanitarian interventions have proven to be atrocities the united states proclaimed themselves to be the guardians of humanitarian intervention in the 90s even though they conducted no humanitarian interventions, but they did commit many awful atrocities. Humanitarian cash transfers and the private sector. Fundamentally, the r2p debate is about whether intervention can achieve its explicit humanitarian objective, which is the main focus of this article. The problem of humanitarian intervention after the cold war 36. However, this is rarely a priority for humanitarian interventions, and making it one. In the wake of the 11 september 2001 attacks on the us, the topic has come under even more discussion. In the first vote on the resolution humanitarian intervention does more harm than good, before the debate, in polling you here in brussels, 30 percent of you agreed with this motion, 51 percent were against the motion, and 19 percent were undecided. Successful humanitarian interventions and war in syria.
In fact, humanitarian intervention is a perfect duty in that the empirical circumstances themselves surrounding human rights crises 4 aidan hehir in humanitarian intervention. Human rights and humanitarian action hpg background paper. Redefining the dilemmas of humanitarian intervention. A learned and stimulating collection of very fine essays on the political, moral and legal aspects of humanitarian intervention. He is the author, inter alia, of justice at a distance. The issue of humanitarian intervention has become increasingly prominent in worldwide debates regarding its role in ethics and legitimacy in international relations. Humanitarian intervention and the distribution of sovereignty in international law patrick macklem september 2006 draft abstract legal debates about humanitarian intervention military intervention by one or more states to curb gross human rights violations occurring in another state tend to assume that its legitimacy. Humanitarian refers principally to the motives for the intervention, namely, to save foreigners from the ills inflicted upon them by their rulers or by powerful, protected groups in their own country. This essay begins with definitional discussions of the key terms of any such debate. Humanitarian intervention doshisha international conference. Humanitarian intervention by vaughan lowe, antonios. Pdf ngos roles in humanitarian interventions and peace. The moral worth of humanitarian intervention rests upon the supreme principle of humanity as an endinitself.
Ngos roles in humanitarian interventions and peace support operations. Consequently, humanitarian intervention can be compared intellectually to 120 affaires courantes et commentaires current issues and comments. When a massive and systematic violation of basic human rights is committed by the authorities of one state, can other states intervene forcefully to halt the. The debate suggests that humanitarian intervention is either legal or illegal depending on ones understanding of how international law is constructed, changed, and represented. Wheeler, tociteonlyoneexample,concludethatnoninterventionistsareunable. Pdf libya and criteria for humanitarian intervention. The question of humanitarian intervention is not a new one. Affaires courantes et commentaires current issues and comments. The dilemma of humanitarian intervention council on foreign. Humanitarian intervention is always cloaked in altruism. Humanitarian intervention and the distribution of sovereignty. Humanitarian cash transfers and the private sector background note for the.
The conflict between principles such as sovereignty and non intervention on one hand and human rights on the other hand is furthermore evident in the debate on humanitarian intervention. The stance of publicists 18301939 on armed humanitarian intervention. The legal status of humanitarian intervention and its relationship to international humanitarian law humanitarian intervention is a jus ad bellumquestion. Armed humanitarian intervention internet encyclopedia of. Humanitarian intervention does more harm than good. The debate on humanitarian intervention watanabe koji china jia qingguo japan murata koji south korea kim sunghan india jasjit singh asean simon s. Has humanitarian intervention become an exception to the. Debating humanitarian intervention should we try to save strangers. Abstract the aim of this paper is to define humanitarian intervention, to analyze its purpose and to evaluate its value in international law.
This chapter analyses the participation of ngos in humanitarian intervention and peace. This trend deserves examining, as it points to a growing interest in. The issue of humanitarian intervention has generated one of the most heated debates in international relations over the past decade, for both theorists and practitioners. Above all the changing practice of humanitarian intervention raises questions about the current structure of the international system. Humanitarian intervention is a use of military force to address extraordinary suffering of people, such as genocide or similar, largescale violation of basic of human rights, where peoples suffering results from their own governments actions or failures to act. Instances of humanitarian intervention according to publicists until the 1930s. Kant and the current debate over humanitarian intervention, 6 journal of transnational law and policy. Pdf humanitarian intervention and the responsibility to protect. Humanitarian intervention has become a major focus of debate within governments, international organizations, and think tanks and across a variety of academic fields, including international and comparative law, international relations, political science, and moral and political philosophy. The united nations in an evolving world orderphiladelphia. Thus, this book provides an important overview of the humanitarian intervention debate and forces the reader to rethink both the conditions under which humanitarian intervention can be justified, as well as the limitations of military responses in addressing humanitarian need. Humanitarian intervention in the long nineteenth century.
At its heart is the alleged tension between the principle of state sovereignty, and the evolving norms related to individual human rights. Humanitarian intervention after syria legal studies. Responsibility to protect, humanitarian intervention and human rights. Humanitarian intervention is an invaluable contribution to the debate on all aspects of this vital global issue. The traditional meaning of the term humanitarian intervention focuses on the use or threat of military force by a state or group of states against another state for humanitarian purposes, a right to humanitarian assistance implies that there is a legal basis to provide emergency relief across borders, even when this is carried out. In tracing the history of the doctrine up to the beginning of the syria crisis, it asserts that the negative reaction to the abortive use of force has reinforced the unlawfulness of humanitarian intervention. Humanitarianrefers principally to the motives for the intervention, namely, to save foreigners from the ills inflicted upon them by their rulers or by powerful, protected groups in their own country. These controversies were preceded by debates about postcold war interventions in northern iraq, somalia, and bosnia and the failure to intervene in. The debate suggests that humanitarian intervention is either legal or illegal. The responsibility to protect often referred to as r2p or rtop aimed to halt atrocities as they occurred, and rebuild and reconstruct societies in the wake of such.
Faced with these dilemmas, should intervention continue to be seen as the appropriate solution for humanitarian crises. Stanley hoffmann harvard university humanitarian intervention lies at the fault line between the international systems commitments to state autonomy and integrity and to the protection of human rights. Humanitarian intervention publish your masters thesis. Oct 22, 2018 10222018 the effect of the intervention in libya on the international debate about syria 2 sovereignty, humanitarian intervention, and international law the concept of sovereignty, as well as that of international law, is usually linked to 16 th and 17 th century european thought and the development of the modern international system. It can be traced back in recognisably modern form to the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, and, in particular, to the writings of victoria 1532, gentili 1598 and grotius 1625. Humanitarian intervention in international law 18301939.
Debating humanitarian intervention paperback fernando r. Affaires courantes et commentaires current issues and. At the heart of the debate lies the tension between the principle of state. Humanitarian intervention on its face incompatible with article 24 81 2. The concept of humanitarian intervention has, almost if not completely exclusively, been used as a veil for selfinterest i challenge anyone to give examples to the contrary. The evolving legitimacy of humanitarian interventions sur. The classical debate about humanitarian intervention. It is a pleasure to be at the brussels forum in partnership with the german marshall fund. Taylor seybolts book is essential reading for anyone interested in humanitarian intervention. Michigan journal of international law humanitarian. While we appreciate that saving lives is important, we ought also save livelihoods. Humanitarian intervention does more harm than good all. However, to minimise the chances of abuse of the principle, certain conditions on humanitarian intervention are needed.
This article calls for a widening of the debate about humanitarian intervention to incorporate insights from constructivism, welsh school critical security studies, and critical approaches to third world international relations. Chapter 2 the ethical debate on humanitarian intervention 41 chapter 3 the changing context of humanitarian intervention 79 chapter 4 international intervention in somalia, 19921995 124 chapter 5 responses to crisis and genocide in rwanda, 19931994 235 conclusion 319 interviews 347 bibliography 352 annex 377 11. Well, we think this has the makings of a debate, so lets have it. This definition may be too narrow as it precludes nonmilitary forms of intervention such as humanitarian aid and international sanctions. Humanitarian intervention, the responsibility to protect, and. Origins and momentum resh attention is focused on the issue of civilian protection by military forces.
Transnational publishers 2005, and dozens of articles in specialized journals. If the international community is to respond to this challenge, the whole debate must be. In the center of the debate on the legality of humanitarian intervention are a number of legal principles on which is built the united nations system, which has provided a certain degree of stability after the end of the war world ii. Cases of genocide and mass violence have raised endless debates about the theory and practice of humanitarian intervention to save innocent lives. Global support for the responsibility to protect doctrine weakened after the unendorsed nofly zone that helped topple libyas regime, and debate. The concept of humanitarian intervention has evolved as a subset of the. Humanitarian intervention that is, military intervention aimed at saving innocent people in other countries from massive violations of human rights primarily the right to life entered public consciousness around 1990 as never before in the course of the twentieth century. Humanitarian intervention has been defined as a states use of military force against another state, with publicly stating its goal is to end human rights violations in that state.
Humanitarian intervention can lead to the rescue of human lives, but can also be abusive. Indeed, internal conflicts are difficult to ignore in a globalizing world. Live debate humanitarian intervention does more harm. We cannot continue to clean the floor while the tap is open. This section will first give an outline of the main issues related to the classical debate, which has been dominated by the english school. Humanitarian intervention as a responsibility to protect. Includes bibliographical references and index the debate on humanitarian intervention watanabe koji china jia qingguo japan murata koji south korea kim sunghan india jasjit singh asean simon s. The origins of the doctrine can be traced to the inception of the modem period and finds its support in.